Cakes & Pies

All cakes are Vanilla and Chocolate Custard layered with Cookie Crunch & Fudge.

GLUTEN FREE CAKES REQUIRE 2 DAYS NOTICE, Please!
SHEET CAKES REQUIRE 2 DAYS NOTICE, Please!

Traditional Birthday

Vanilla and Chocolate Custard, layered with Cookie Crunch & Fudge

6" Round $29.958" Round $35.9510" Round $40.951/4 Sheet $59.951/2 Sheet $82.95

19 reviews

114116 likes19 reviews

Peanut Butter Fudge Cake

Vanilla & chocolate custard with a cookie crunch center with Peanut Butter and Fudge. Topped with Fudge, Peanut Butter and Peanut Butter Cups.

6" Round $35.958" Round $41.9510" Round $46.951/4 Sheet $70.951/2 Sheet $102.95

18 reviews

114318 likes18 reviews

Oreo Fudge Cake

Topped with Oreo cookies, with a chopped Oreo and fudge center, then drizzled with fudge!

6" Round $35.958" Round $41.9510" Round $46.951/4 Sheet $70.951/2 Sheet $102.95

5 reviews

Turtle Sundae Cake

Top Seller! Vanilla & chocolate custard layered with cookie crunch, fudge, and caramel. Topped with Fudge, Caramel & Pecans

Note: We cannot write on this cake.

6" Round $35.958" Round $41.9510" Round $46.951/4 Sheet $70.951/2 Sheet $102.95

12 reviews

527 likes12 reviews

Peanut Butter Custard Pie

PRE-ORDER FOR NOVEMBER 19-22 PICK UP! Peanut Butter Custard in graham cracker pie shell, topped with fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cup pieces and whipped frosting! Gluten free available!

Serves 6-8 $29.95

Featured

8 reviews

112 likes8 reviews

Mafia Football Ice Cream Cake

Vanilla and Chocolate Custard, layered with Cookie Crunch & Fudge

8" Round $35.9510" Round $40.951/4 sheet $59.951/2 sheet $82.95

Rainbow Ice Cream Cake

Vanilla and Chocolate Custard, layered with Cookie Crunch & Fudge

8" Round $41.9510" Round $46.951/4 sheet $70.951/2 sheet $102.95

1 review

Pumpkin Custard Pie

PRE-ORDER FOR NOVEMBER 19-22 PICK UP! Graham Cracker Crust filled with Frozen Pumpkin Custard, topped with caramel and dash of cinnamon!

Serves 6-8 $29.95

Featured

2 reviews

Maple Pecan Custard Pie

PRE-ORDER FOR NOVEMBER 19-22 PICK UP! Creamy frozen maple custard in a graham cracker crust, drizzled with caramel and topped with candied pecans and dollops of whipped topping!

Serves 6-8 $29.95

Oreo Custard Pie

PRE-ORDER FOR NOVEMBER 19-22 PICK UP! Chocolate graham cracker crust filled with frozen vanilla custard, topped with fudge and Oreo pieces and dollops of whipped topping!

Serves 6-8 $29.95

Show All Items

Gluten-Free